The September Society Read online

  Also by Charles Finch

  A Beautiful Blue Death

  THE

  SEPTEMBER SOCIETY

  Charles Finch

  St. Martin’s Minotaur New York

  This is a work of fiction. All of the characters, organizations, and events

  portrayed in this novel are either products of the author’s imagination or

  are used fictitiously.

  THE SEPTEMBER SOCIETY. Copyright © 2008 by Charles Finch. All rights

  reserved. Printed in the United States of America. For information,

  address St. Martin’s Press, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010.

  www.minotaurbooks.com

  Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

  Finch, Charles (Charles B.)

  The September Soceity/Charles Finch.—1st ed.

  p. cm.

  ISBN-13: 978-0-312-35978-2

  ISBN-10: 0-312-35978-0

  1. Private investigators—England—Fiction. 2. Missing persons—

  Investigation—Fiction. 3. College students—England—Fiction.

  4. Lincoln College (University of Oxford)—Fiction. I. Title.

  PS3606.I526S46 2008

  813′.6—dc22

  2008003452

  First Edition: August 2008

  10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1

  For Rosie, Julia, Henry, and Isabelle,

  with a brother’s deepest love

  Contents

  Cover Page

  Other Books By This Author

  Title Page

  Copyright

  Dedication

  Acknowledgments

  Prologue

  Chapter One

  Chapter Two

  Chapter Three

  Chapter Four

  Chapter Five

  Chapter Six

  Chapter Seven

  Chapter Eight

  Chapter Nine

  Chapter Ten

  Chapter Eleven

  Chapter Twelve

  Chapter Thirteen

  Chapter Fourteen

  Chapter Fifteen

  Chapter Sixteen

  Chapter Seventeen

  Chapter Eighteen

  Chapter Nineteen

  Chapter Twenty

  Chapter Twenty-One

  Chapter Twenty-Two

  Chapter Twenty-Three

  Chapter Twenty-Four

  Chapter Twenty-Five

  Chapter Twenty-Six

  Chapter Twenty-Seven

  Chapter Twenty-Eight

  Chapter Twenty-Nine

  Chapter Thirty

  Chapter Thirty-One

  Chapter Thirty-Two

  Chapter Thirty-Three

  Chapter Thirty-Four

  Chapter Thirty-Five

  Chapter Thirty-Six

  Chapter Thirty-Seven

  Chapter Thirty-Eight

  Chapter Thirty-Nine

  Chapter Forty

  Chapter Forty-One

  Chapter Forty-Two

  Chapter Forty-Three

  Chapter Forty-Four

  Chapter Forty-Five

  Chapter Forty-Six

  Chapter Forty-Seven

  Chapter Forty-Eight

  Chapter Forty-Nine

  Chapter Fifty

  Chapter Fifty-One

  Chapter Fifty-Two

  ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

  I’m profoundly thankful to the people who made this book possible: Kate Lee, Charles Spicer, Michael Homler, Hector DeJean, Tara Cibelli, Larissa Silva, Sam Truitt, Louise Crelly, Harriet Bloomstein, James Dawson, John Hill, Richard Mc-Cabe, Stephen Finch, Charles Finch, Angela Finch, and, of course, Anne Truitt.

  I’m also blessed with amazing friends: Rachel Blitzer, Matt McCarthy, John Phillips, Chris Compton, Dan Compton, Tom Jenkins, James Kelly, Nuala Trainor, Rob Crowe, Laurence Publicover, Sarah Tate, Kelly Jones, and the terrific Emily Popp.

  My good friend Ben Reiter read an early draft of The September Society and improved it substantially with his suggestions.

  I Want to reserve special mention for my parents: for my father, who has given me much love and support, and my mother, who remembers all those trips to the library and who has always been my best friend.

  PROLOGUE

  The first murders were committed nineteen years before the second, on a dry and unremarkable day along the Sutlej Frontier in Punjab.

  It was beastly hot weather, as Juniper remarked to Captain Lysander out on the veranda of the officers’ mess, fit for little more than an odd gin and tonic, perhaps the lazy composition of a letter home. The flies, maddening creatures that had never learned to take no for an answer, crowded around the nets that blocked the porch, searching for a way in. “I would trade a hand to be back in London,” Lysander said to Juniper after a long pause. “At least they have the decency to bar these flies from coming into the city there.”

  The battalion was on edge, because a recent retaliatory raid on a local village had turned bloody. Suspicion and rumor abounded. The officers, with a few exceptions, had long ceased to attend to their charges’ morale. Though all the Englishmen in Punjab lived well, with villas and servants to themselves, every one of them at that uneasy moment would have made the trade Lysander proposed.

  “Well,” said Juniper. “I may go look around and have a bit of a shoot with Jim.”

  “Were you planning that?”

  “Oh, yes.”

  “Where do you reckon you’ll go?”

  “That little patch of scrub east of here. Doubt we’ll find anything worth a bullet. Maybe a darkie or two, looking for trouble.”

  Lysander smiled grimly. “Past that little grove of banyan trees, then?”

  “Curious today, aren’t you?”

  In another place this might have sounded rude, but being white was a great equalizer in that country, and these men were too intimate to maintain entirely the ceremonies of respect and rank that defined the British.

  “Always on the lookout for a decent bit of shooting, you know,” responded Lysander, sipping his gin and tonic. He was a trim, forceful, savvy-looking man. “D’you know why they give us so much tonic, young pup?”

  “No. Why?”

  “Has quinine in it. Prevents malaria.”

  “I suppose I did know that, actually.”

  “They must’ve told you in training.”

  “Yes,” said Juniper, nodding agreeably.

  “Just past that grove of banyan trees, then?” There was a slight, casual persistence in Lysander’s voice. “Ever shot anything edible there?”

  “Not to speak of. There are a few birds, not much on the ground. It’s poor sport.”

  “So’s this whole country.”

  “Any more inspirational speech before I leave?”

  “On your way.”

  Juniper stood up. “I’m sure I’ll see you for cocktails.”

  But he wouldn’t, and the other man knew it.

  When Juniper had gone out of sight, Lysander leapt out of his chair and walked briskly up a small dirt path that led from the mess to his villa. The captain’s batman, his assistant and a lance corporal, was on the porch, whittling an Indian charm to send back to his mother. He had been working on it for weeks.

  “Best go do it now,” Lysander said. “He’s off with Juniper. Both of them, would you? They’re hunting, out east, in that scrub.”

  “Yes, sir,” said the batman, standing. Here rank still meant something.

  “Do your best to make it look like an accident, obviously.”

  “Yes, sir.”

  Lysander paused. “By the way, that treasure?”

  “Yes, sir?”

  “There’s talk of a society. Don’t know what it’s to be called y
et, and it will be for officers alone.”

  “Sir?”

  “But if you do right by us, we’ll do right by you.”

  “Thank you, sir.”

  The batman ran off, and Lysander called to one of the servants, a fair Indian lad, swathed in brilliant pink and pale blue that contrasted with the dull beige of the landscape and the military man’s uniform. The boy with some sullenness came forward.

  “That box,” Lysander barked. “Bring it to me. And it’s worth your life to open it before it gets here.”

  A moment later he was holding the box, and, when certain he was alone, he opened it to reveal a massive, pristine, and beautiful sapphire.

  As he snapped the box shut and had it taken away, Juniper and his friend Jim emerged from the latter’s house, guns broken over their arms, both wearing beige, broad-brimmed hats to keep the dying sun off of their necks and faces. They had a bantering style of conversation that sounded as if it had been picked up from a thousand other conversations before. It was clear how much closer they were than Juniper and Lysander.

  “A farthing says you’ll never eat what you shoot,” Juniper said with a laugh.

  “A farthing? I’ve played higher stakes than that with women.”

  “That serving girl of mine you like, then.”

  “What do I have to eat?”

  “First thing either of us shoots.”

  “What if it’s the dirt?”

  “Bet’s a bet.”

  “How much dirt would I have to eat?”

  “Nice haunch of it.”

  “Farthing for the first meat, let’s go back to that. Don’t shoot anything too horrible.”

  “I’m insulted you’d suggest it.”

  It was a little more than a mile outside of camp, away from Lahore—and that city’s dangers, which these two men knew all too well—that they found a decent patch of land. It had a few bushes and trees scattered around it. They didn’t have a dog, but Juniper shot into the undergrowth and drove a few birds out into the open, where the two men had a clear look at them.

  They observed the birds fluttering, partially obscured, soon to be dead. Ruminatively, Juniper said, “What do you miss most? About England?”

  His interlocutor thought it over. “I wish I hadn’t left it so badly with my family, you know. I miss them.”

  “I do, too.”

  “Only six months, I suppose.”

  Then both men heard a scratching emerge from the undergrowth that lay off to their side.

  A Shot. The Fall Of A Body. Another shot. The fall of a body. A Lone figure, lysander’s batman, rose from his hidden Spot and ran off full bore back west. and then a long, long silence, in the empty land that stretched blank as far as the eye could see, in every direction, forty-five hundred miles away from piccadilly circus.

  CHAPTER ONE

  The only question left, he felt, was how to handle the matter—how it was to be done. Not if, for he had made his mind up entirely. Nor when; the moment would arise on its own.

  But how?

  Charles Lenox, noted amateur detective and scion of an ancient Sussex family, spent most of the morning of September 2, 1866, wandering around his study and pondering his few, daunting options. Normally imperturbable, he seemed during these long hours like a restless man. To begin he would sit heavily in one of the two armchairs by the low fire; then he would lean forward to tap the tobacco ash from his pipe into the embers; then he would stand up and walk across the room to shuffle the letters on his desk, or switch one book with another in the shelves along the wall, or straighten a picture that was to some imperceptible degree tilted; then he would return to his armchair, fill his pipe, and begin the entire dance again.

  He was a lean man with a friendly face—even in the morning’s preoccupation—hazel eyes, and a short brown beard. His carriage was upright, and as he paced he clasped his hands behind his back. It gave him a pensive air, the kind he had during the most difficult moments of his cases. But there was no case at hand this morning.

  All of this pacing and worrying and sitting and standing took place in a handsome white house on Hampden Lane, just off Grosvenor Square. Fifteen paces down the front hall and to the right was this large library, a rectangular, high-ceilinged room with a desk near the door, a fireplace and chairs at the end of the room, a row of tall windows along the front wall, and books everywhere else. It was where he spent the great majority of his time at home, both anxious and happy alike. He pondered his cases there, and on wet, foggy days like this one, he pondered the world—or the part of it that Hampden Lane occupied—through his trickling windowpanes.

  At ten he rang for coffee and at a quarter past he rang to have it taken away, cold and untouched. Graham, his butler, looked concerned but said nothing as he came to and fro. By eleven, however, he could no longer prevent himself from intervening, and presented himself unbidden in the dark oak doorway of the room.

  At that moment Lenox had just taken up residence at his desk, where he was looking across the street at the bookshop.

  “May I get you anything else, sir?” Graham said.

  “No, no,” said Lenox distractedly, still peering through the rain-touched window.

  “If I may venture to say so, sir, you seem anxious.”

  In many of the aristocratic Mayfair households surrounding Hampden Lane, such a statement would have seemed like the highest impertinence. Lenox and Graham had a long and complex history, though, and in the end were friends more than master and man. While Graham, a sandy-haired man with perfectly arranged clothes and a strong, utterly honest face, always spoke and behaved respectfully, he never hesitated to disagree with Lenox, often helped the detective in his work, and even, on rare occasions, spoke with the frankness he just had.

  “Eh?” said Lenox, at last looking up. “Oh, no, Graham—no, thank you, I’m quite all right.”

  “Will you take your lunch here in the library, sir?”

  “No,” said Lenox. “Thanks, I’m having lunch in the City, actually. I shall be glad to get on the other side of these four walls.”

  “Indeed, sir,” said Graham. He paused before adding, “I am in the hall if you require anything.”

  “Thank you,” said Lenox.

  Graham withdrew then, and Lenox sighed. Well! he thought to himself. If Graham had noticed, it had gone too far. He would have to stop worrying and go to lunch with his brother. Standing with a decisive air, Lenox patted the pockets of his jacket and went through the double doors of the library out into the hallway.

  “Graham, will you call out the carriage, please? I think I’ll leave now.”

  “Of course, sir.”

  “I’ll be waiting at Chaffanbrass’s while they rub down the horses.”

  “Yes, sir,” Graham said as he began to walk downstairs. “It shouldn’t be longer than a quarter of an hour.”

  In the front hall, Lenox took his overcoat down from its peg and pulled his umbrella out of its stand. Then he took a breath, ducked outside into the rain, and crossed the street, dodging several hansom cabs and a landau with no inconsiderable agility to get to the bookshop. He pulled open the door and saw the proprietor.

  “Mr. Chaffanbrass,” he said with a smile. “How do you do?”

  “Mr. Lenox!” said Mr. Chaffanbrass, beaming at him from behind a small counter. “Happy anniversary!”

  “Oh?”

  “The fire!”

  “Ah, of course.”

  As it happened, that very day, September 2, was the two hundredth anniversary of the Great Fire of 1666; what had started as a minor conflagration at the Pudding Lane bakery of Thomas Farriner, baker to Charles II, eventually consumed four-fifths of central London. By some miracle only a handful of people had died—the traditional count was reckoned at eight—but thirteen thousand buildings and nearly a hundred churches had vanished. Of the eighty thousand residents of the city, seventy thousand were left homeless. In a year that was already being heralded in some parts as the apocal
ypse because it contained the Number of the Beast, 666, few needed persuading in the first heady hours after the three-day blaze that the world was at an end.

  “And yet,” said Lenox, “my grandfather always said the fire did our city two great services.”

  “What do you mean?”

  “For one thing, it allowed Wren to build his fifty churches, as well as St. Paul’s Cathedral. The fire is the reason we live in such a beautiful city, Mr. Chaffanbrass.”

  “And the second reason?”

  “Do you know how many people died of the plague in 1665?”

  “How many?”

  “About sixty-five thousand, and that despite two-thirds of Londoners leaving the city. The fire killed so many rats and fleas, leveled so many derelict buildings, that in the end it probably saved tens of thousands of lives.”

  Ruminatively, Mr. Chaffanbrass said, “Perhaps it’s received a bad press, then.”

  “Perhaps,” Lenox agreed. “Still, it would be better all around if it didn’t happen again. Incidentally, has my copy of Pickwick come in yet?”

  “It hasn’t yet, I very much fear.”

  “Can’t be helped,” said Lenox.

  “It will prove worth the wait, though! The finest red leather, with gold inlay!”

  “And all the words inside?”